240. Why the American Psychological Association Doubled Down on Gender Medicine | Joe Figliolia
Download MP3Joe: They literally argue that
your gender is more real than your
sex, and your gender is defined in
relation to sex stereotypes, and then
your sex is basically determined by
which stereotypes you conform to.
It's strange to me how anyone could absorb
th- this idea and not immediately be
like, "Yeah, this is crazy to think that a
seven-year-old has a working understanding
of gender as independent than sex."
Announcer: You must be
some kind of therapist?
Stephanie: Today I'm welcoming
to the podcast Joe Figliolia.
He's a policy analyst at the Manhattan
Institute, where he researches
and writes about policies related
to so-called gender identity.
His writing has appeared in City Journal,
The Dispatch, the New York Post, UnHerd,
The Daily Wire, and RealClearPolicy.
Today is a part of a series of episodes
I'm doing on the APA, the American
Psychological Association, which Joe has
covered in some of his recent articles.
Joe, welcome.
Good to see you.
Joe: Good to see you too, Stephanie.
Thanks for having me.
Stephanie: I'd like to start with
your professional background.
You and I originally met a couple
years ago when you interviewed me
for an article you wrote on the
so-called conversion therapy bans.
Um, so tell us how someone I, I met in
this journalistic cons- context, tell
us how you got here to focusing on the
field of psychology and matters of gender.
Joe: Yeah, that's a good question.
Uh, so before I worked in the,
the policy space, I worked, uh, in
psychiatric research, uh, specifically
neuroimaging, uh, for the co- Columbia
Department of Psychiatry and the New
York State Psychiatric Institute.
And, uh, I was thinking about a career
as a clinical psychologist, and I, uh,
I was getting a master's degree at the
time in a sort of a broadly humanistic
program, but most of my coursework ended
up, uh, focusing on psychology, but I
ended up taking more courses on sort of
the history and philosophy of psychology,
philosophy of emotion, sort of the
philosophy of psychopathology, so kind of
moving in a slightly different direction.
Um, and I was also working as a course
instructor for clinical psychology.
So, uh, I think that, uh, part- The
gender stuff was not necessarily, uh,
at the front of my radar at the time,
but it became around that same time I
came across Lisa Littman's, uh, paper
on ROGD and the kind of general public
response to that paper and the backlash,
uh, I, I found super interesting 'cause
I thought that, you know, the community,
the psychological community, if there was
a, a new, uh, gender dysphoric population
would, would be curious to hear about,
you know, what makes this population
different, how are their needs different.
And I was very surprised that there was
this attempt to kind of, uh, critique and
silence the research, I think because it
challenged a lot of the assumptions that
sort of, uh, gender identity is innate
and immutable and things like that.
Stephanie: What you witnessed with the
response to Lisa Littman's research on
ROGD, was that part of what made you
decide to not pursue a clinical path?
Joe: The main reason I decided not to
pursue a clinical path was really that the
programs at the time I was, I was looking
at were, I would say, pretty politicized.
This was 2020, uh, so like the aftermath
of the George Floyd protests, and I
noticed a lot of programs that I was
looking at were, you know, explicitly
requiring sort of like political
commitments and I had to write, uh, a
number of anti-racist essays as well.
And I just kinda didn't wanna deal
with that sort of environment,
uh, in graduate school.
And so, uh, in a different lifetime
I would probably have pursued
that career path, but I don't
think it was the right fit for me.
Um, at this moment in time
Stephanie: It's so sad.
I, I hear from people like you all
the time, people a little bit younger
than myself, early in their career,
thoughtful, um, really wanting a, a
meaningful career that makes a difference,
people maybe with a natural talent for
psychology and counseling and who just
happened to be coming into that chapter
of their lives at the wrong time during
this particular political climate.
And so I think you are an example
of a phenomenon that I want our
listeners to witness and that many
of them are themselves a part of.
I think it's sad because it means that
we're losing contributions to the field
that could be incredibly valuable.
At the same time, it seems like
you're not out of luck here.
You've, you've found a different path.
So tell us where your career has
led you and what your focus is now.
Joe: So my focus right now
is, uh, in the policy arena.
So I basically work on policies
and write about and analyze
policies related to, to gender,
particularly youth gender medicine.
Um, so thinking about kind of the
institutional aspects of that, you
know, the clinical aspects, trying to
understand, you know, how, uh, medical
associations sort of shape policy in this
area, how, you know, despite a lack of
evidence, uh, in support of, uh, youth
medical transition, how you could be--
how we could be in a position where until
fairly recently with the American Society
of Plastic Surgeons sort of breaking
with, uh, the, the Medical Association
consensus and the American College of
Pediatricians, uh, every mainstream
medical association, including the
American Psychological Association, which
I know we're gonna talk about, uh, has
basically endorsed this practice, and,
uh, not just endorsed it, but endorsed it,
uh, with force and really come acro- uh,
really, um throwing their weight behind
these policies and sort of presenting
youth gender medicine as evidence-based,
life-saving, uh, medically necessary.
And I think by, you know, by the
standards of evidence-based medicine,
uh, sort of none of those things are,
are actually true, and it's kind of a
really interesting, uh, predicament.
Stephanie: All right.
So let's dive straight into it then.
What can you tell us about the APA?
It seems like they've been
on my radar a lot lately.
There's a lot kind of going down with
the APA losing their accreditation
status recently, for example.
Um, things really seem
to be coming to a head.
So how long ha- has the
APA been on your radar?
Tell us what you've been noticing
about them or learning about them.
Joe: Yeah.
So the APA has been on my radar for a
while in, you know, for a few reasons.
One, it's, you know, the, the main
sort of psychological association
I think sets, you know, standards
and sort of best practices for
the psych community at large.
And the psych community in, you know,
the gender medicine space are often the
ones that are supposed to be screening
patients, doing psychological assessment,
making recommendations, uh, whether
or not, you know, these interventions
are in the best interest of patients.
And so they play a key role there.
And I think I was struck by, you know, the
American Psychological Association, uh,
over the last few years, uh, like a lot of
other medical associations, uh, throwing
their weight behind youth gender medicine.
So in amicus briefs in
the case of Skrmetti v.
United States, which was, uh, the lawsuit
regarding Tennessee's, uh, ban on youth
gender medicine, uh, they've released a
quite a controversial position statement
in 2024, where they basically assert
that, again, that youth gender medicine
is evidence-based and life-saving.
And it goes a step further where
it actually labels criticism of the
affirmative model as misinformation.
And so by that, by their own standards
then, you're getting into this
uncomfortable situation where, you
know, the findings from evidence
reviews in countries like the UK,
Sweden, and Finland would constitute
misinformation by the APA standards.
And it's also worth mentioning that the,
the issues with the APA are not solely
about, uh, gender and gender ideology.
Uh, what was interesting when
that-- So the National Committee
on, uh, Na- uh, Education Quality
and Integrity recommended to suspend
the APA's accreditation status.
It has not actually been, uh, that has
not actually been made official yet.
So the recommendation is to suspend, but
it actually requires the undersecretary of
the Department of Education to then sort
of accept the recommendation, and they
were given 90 days for that to happen.
And as far as I know, there's
been no movement there.
But what is interesting is that
DOE staff, in a report prior
to that committee meeting,
recommended to re-accredit the APA.
So it seemed like their initial move
prior to that hearing was very much to
move forward, and after the hearing,
uh, there was enough concerns raised
where they decided to recommend against.
And a lot of the complaints were not about
gender, although that did happen, but
a lot of them were about complaints of
antisemitism in APA programs, the failure
to investigate complaints of antisemitism,
and sort of the problems with teaching.
And you probably know more about this
than I do, but sort of the teaching
of critical psychotherapies, these
kind of, uh, colonial, post-colonial
frameworks you would call them, where,
uh, Jews are often depicted as, you
know, settler colonialists or, or
white supremacists in this hierarchy.
And so I think a lot of Jewish
students felt sort of unfairly
targeted in these programs.
Um- And that was actually not on
my radar as much at the time that
this was such a, such a problem.
But I, I actually attended the, the
committee hearing, um, online and
gave comments, and I was struck by
the, just the, the sheer number of
comments about antisemitism in the APA.
And, um, it's also worth for, uh, for
the, for the, for the listeners to know
that the APA's status as an accreditor,
there's the APA and then there's the APA's
Commission on Accreditation, which is
technically a separate accrediting entity.
And all this activity has been about
the Commission on Accreditation.
But of course, the, you know, the question
becomes is how, how independent are
these associations, and do the APA's
policies and position statements and
commitments, um, do those, you know,
trickle down into their actual programs?
And I think it's hard for me to, to-- it's
hard for me to take seriously the idea
that these are totally separate entities
and that, you know, what the APA does
has no bearing on sort of the commission.
Stephanie: Yeah, I think the
cultural rot probably goes a lot
deeper than something like the APA's
accreditation status being revoked.
And I didn't know that
that was just a suggestion.
I thought it had been completed.
Um, for your context, Joe, as well
as for our listeners, one of the
other people I'm interviewing right
around the same time is John Mills.
So, um, that-- we happen to be recording
this episode the afternoon of the
morning that I recorded with John Mills.
Now, for our listeners, I might end up
releasing this episode with Joe Figliolia
before the episode with John Mills.
I might make that decision kind of
depending on which episode I think does
a better job of laying the foundation
of what is going on with the APA.
So, uh, depending on sort of which
order I release in and which order
listeners are listening in, um, I can
point you to that conversation with
John Mills about antisemitism because
he was actually one of the members of
the APA on the Listserv who was noticing
those problems with antisemitism coming
from someone in a position of power.
And so that's part of how we got here.
Joe: Quick interjection as well
that last week House Republicans
made comments about apparently leaked
materials, email exchanges, where they
also accused the APA of, of essentially
antisemitism in their programs.
I haven't followed the details of that,
but I did see the, the headlines as well.
So this is not, it's not
coming from one place.
It seems to be, yeah, a,
an institutional issue.
Stephanie: Yeah, and antisemitism
seems like where a lot of the woke
identity politics stuff gets, uh, kind
of starts to eat its own tail, right?
'Cause the, the woke lens creates
this very black and white hierarchy.
There's even this thing called the
wheel of oppression where you can
locate where you are on the spectrum
between what they deem oppressed and
what they d- deem privileged on all
these different demographic markers.
Um- And I think antisemitism i- is
the place where the ideology starts
to break down, because, you know,
obviously historically Jews have been
a minority that have been oppressed and
enslaved, and yet they're the minority
that it's okay to hate 'cause they're
White, and it just gets really tricky.
Joe: I remember several years ago,
I forget where the article was written.
This was a number of years ago, and Bari
Weiss, uh, wrote an article where she
basically observed something similar,
that sort of the unique status of, of
Jews was kind of breaking the brains
of a lot of social justice advocates
'cause they didn't know, like, what to
do with them or how to, how to categorize
them for these exact reasons, that they
wanna put them in, you know, the White
oppressor category, but that, that
doesn't work for historical reasons.
And so it sort of, uh, they just kinda
don't know what to do, and they're in
this kind of shadow, shadow position.
Stephanie: Hmm, but tell us more about
the gender medicine nonsense angle.
You said you've been tracking it
since at least 2024, when you said the
APA submitted an amicus brief in the
Skrmetti versus United States case.
Joe: Yeah, so basically, uh, you
know, and they're not the only medical
association that, that done, that has done
this, and a lot of them are, are fairly
cookie cutter, often, you know, using,
uh, WPATH, uh, the US Endocrine Society
as kind of, uh, you know, the two kind
of linchpins that hold up the sort of,
uh, the whole gender medicine machine.
And so, uh, for those that don't
know, but WPATH, extremely influential
organization in this space, the World
Professional Association for Transgender
Health, and, uh, the US Endocrine
Society, they have clinical practice
guidelines that both come out in, in,
in favor of youth gender medicine.
A lot of controversies about, about both,
about both of these, but essentially
in the amicus brief, they support, uh,
these clinical practice guidelines.
They frame gender medicine as
evidence-based, life-saving,
medically necessary.
And, uh, in subsequent documents, they've
also gone on to, I think, I think, and
I think this is a huge problem with
the social justice kind of ideology in
general, but they frame the issue of youth
gender medicine, especially in their more
recent 2024 document, as primarily sort
of a, a civil rights issue and a question
of, of human rights and, and human
autonomy and, you know, bodily autonomy.
And while that is, like, one angle with
which you could consider, you know,
this question, I think it's also an
inappropriate one F- for a few reasons.
One, you know, auton- the autonomy angle
doesn't override, you know, questions
of medical efficacy or evidence.
And so the first question should
just be, do these interventions,
you know, actually work?
And again, according to the standards
of systematic reviews of evidence with
which evaluate evidence quality, you
know, youth gender medicine has very
low certainty evidence for benefit.
By the standards of systematic reviews,
there's also low evidence for risks.
But given what we know about human
physiology, it doesn't take a
stretch to see that, you know, there
are consequences, for example, for
using, for males that take estrogen,
females that take testosterone,
elevated cardiovascular cancer risk.
It leads to, in, in women, the
collapsing of the pelvic floor.
Uh, there's, there's lots of serious
health risks and a lot, a lot of which
are unknown because of the lack of
longitudinal data, um, in this area.
And so, you know, the APA, you know,
kind of sidestepping the question of
medical efficacy and just presenting
this as a human rights issue, I think
is, is irresponsible from the, in the
sense that it doesn't prepare people for
actually thinking about, does this work?
What is in the best interests
of, of gender dysphoric minors?
Um, and I think that's kind of
the, the, that's the real kind of
insidious nature of that framing.
Stephanie: Here's a couple different
angles I, I think about on this issue.
One is that gender ideology has
started this trend of identifying as.
And so WPATH identifies as
a professional organization.
Um, they make things that they identify
as standard of, standards of care.
And youth gender medicine
identifies as evidence-based
and identifies as life-saving.
And, uh, as we've explored abundantly on
this podcast, identifying as something
does not actually make that true.
And I think the question of do
these interventions work becomes
muddied because the question is
work, uh, to accomplish what exactly?
When you have a medical condition
With known biomarkers, then those
biomarkers become evidence of
whether or not something worked.
But as we know, with youth gender
medicine, there are no biomarkers.
There are no brain scans or blood tests.
Anecdotally, there's plenty of
evidence that there's overlap with
autism, obsessive compulsive disorder,
cluster B personality disorders, and
in girls, polycystic ovarian syndrome.
So anecdotally, plenty of evidence
for overlap with those conditions.
Um, and, you know, we've also
anecdotally gotten evidence that
treating those underlying conditions
helped with the so-called dysphoria.
You know, something like PCOS, for
instance, um, does include girls having
abnormally high testosterone levels
and abnormally low progesterone levels.
So this is one place where I get
pushback from my gender-critical
friends and colleagues when I say
things like, "Maybe there is some
degree of physical reality found in
the body behind some girls' claims, for
instance, to feel less feminine," right?
If we find that girls with PCOS Are
more often presenting, complaining of
something called gender dysphoria, and
we know that PCOS involves high androgen
levels and low progesterone levels.
Why wouldn't you consider that this isn't
necessarily just 100% social contagion?
It still can be significantly
social contagion and significantly
psychological in nature.
I, I see your face.
Let me finish my point, though.
Joe: Sorry, yeah, go ahead.
My wheels are turning already, but-
Stephanie: Yeah, I know.
But, I mean, my point is to the
question of do these things work, right?
Work as treatments for what?
If the body wasn't sick in the first
place, all we know is that these
so-called treatments make the body sicker.
Meanwhile, the goalposts shift in terms of
resolution of psychological symptoms, and
that's where- I would- I obviously have
a lot more to say, but please go ahead.
Joe: Yeah, and I wanna talk about the
goalpost shifting, 'cause I think that's
extremely important, and I wanna talk
about the, this paper that came out maybe
a year or two ago by one of the founders
of the Dutch protocol who pioneered youth
gender medicine, where they essentially
talk about redefining what it means for
outcomes to be effective in this space.
And it's basically their way of
acknowledging that there's no evidence
for benefit, so that instead of, uh…
Instead they need to kind of create an
alternative justification for doing this,
and they, they arrive at basically bodily
autonomy as the sole guiding principle.
And, and in fact, they make comments
about how, like, negative affect is,
is built into the human experience
and so is, so is patient regret.
And so who are we to sort of stand
in the way of, of, of minors and
their self-determination and their…
It's, it's quite interesting, and
it's, 'cause it's, it's very unusual
and it doesn't operate within, as
you said, this traditional medical
paradigm where you have an underlying
pathophysiology that we can point to
and say like, "Okay, you have heart
disease," like, "We know how to fix this."
Gender dysphoria is a lot more nebulous,
where I think that no one would dispute
that the distress that the patients
feel is real, but there's all kinds
of reasons why they could experience
that distress, some of which that have
nothing to do with dysphoria itself.
And we can get into the question of,
you know, false self-appraisals where
any, any type of diffuse negative affect
can sort of be interpreted as dysphoria
when this sort of- The paradigm is out
there that if you feel different or
uncomfortable or bad, that you might
just be the, you know, the opposite sex.
And I think that you made a good point
about sort of what is the goal of
treatment, and I think it used to be
this idea that the justification for
the Dutch protocol originally was this
idea of, like, appearance congruence,
that if you look like the, the way
you feel inside, that that would auto-
that, that would automatically kind
of resolve dysphoria or distress.
But then what's interesting
is that you have these newer,
you know, conceptualizations.
Are you- I'm sure you're familiar with,
like, the gender incongruence paradigm,
which is just the idea that, you know, we
don't even care about distress anymore.
The only thing that makes you transgender
is if you have a identity that's different
than your sex, for example, and that's it.
Like, that is, that is the
basis for interventions.
But then you get into this really
interesting kind of paradox where
it's a normal state of being in the
world, and you're just, there's no
right or wrong way to be trans, and
it's not a pathological condition.
But then how can it also then be
needed to do medical interventions
in order to treat that?
It, like, doesn't, it
doesn't map appropriately.
It's a very strange sort of, uh, sort
of framework, and the more I think about
it, the more I'm just kind of fascinated
that these ideas were allowed to kind
of flourish and not be second-guessed.
Stephanie: Your trans-identified
adolescent or young adult won't
listen to reason because reason
isn't what they need right now.
They need a parent who
knows how to reach them.
Every parent gets stuck
in a different way.
Some freeze.
Some over-research.
Some keep apologizing for boundaries
they have every right to set.
Take my free eight-minute
quiz at rogdrepair.com/quiz.
You'll get your parent archetype and
the ROGD Repair lessons chosen for
your pattern, plus a code for half
off your first month.
That's rogdrepair.com/quiz.
Stephanie: I can tell that we're
going to get into some of the
psychology of this together, and
you, you have that background.
You have that natural inclination
for psychology, even if you
didn't become a clinician.
You know, hopefully we'll talk about some
of the, the stuff that's more in your
wheelhouse than mine, the, you know, the
APA and everything that's going on there.
Let's go there.
I mean, because this concept of congruence
Let's break that down for a moment, right?
For one, we know that this is, this
is a path of endless goalpost shifting
in the sense that a- as we've come to
say, the dysphoria moves around, right?
That, and this is part of why we look at
the overlap between the concept of gender
dysphoria and the concept of obsessive
compulsive disorder because there is
a, a fixation, intense rumination.
There are behaviors that reinforce
the belief system, right?
And so that fixation can
target a certain body part.
It can target most commonly in
girls the breasts, but the face,
the voice, the throat, the height,
the shape, and all of that, um,
can become a subject of fixation.
And we know that After young people
do make some permanent change to
whatever body part they've been
fixated on, there's often a short-term
period of so-called euphoria,
also known as the placebo effect.
You got the thing you told yourself
would m- make all the difference,
and then eventually that wears away.
Your underlying mental patterns that
you've been practicing for years
are still there, so the feelings
come back, the target shifts, right?
So we know that when it comes to the
concept of congruence, that chasing
this idea of congruence can be very
dangerous, and it's often tragically
only after so many body modifications
that a young person realizes they're
chasing this idea of congruence.
But I also wanna kinda conceptually
break it down too, because the idea of
feeling consistent on the inside and
the outside, of feeling recognized for
who you are, i- if you take away all
the kinda cultural narratives around
it, that's a universal human desire,
and it's a process that's supposed to be
happening in adolescence and adulthood
as you live and form a personality and
form relationships and get, as I say in
my course, ROGD Repair, tumbled smooth.
Your character becomes tumbled smooth like
a rock moving through the river of life,
bumping up against people and experiences,
and eventually you come to take shape.
So it's not wrong to want that, and this
is what's so predatory and parasitic
about gender ideology is it takes these
things that are natural about young
people, like the desire for congruence
and the sense that one hasn't fully
achieved it yet, and twists it into this
idea of what will get you there, and
takes away a young person's openness to
any other ideas of what could actually
create that sense of congruence for them.
Joe: I think it definitely is a
kind of a perfect storm where young,
a lot of young people are sort of
dealing with, well, all of them are
dealing with sort of questions about
identity when they're teenagers.
And I think the, the gender stuff
is kind of just another sort of, is
I think a way for a lot of people
to kind of navigate like a, a
developmental challenge in a way.
It's really interesting to me in a
lot of the research that I've seen
and, uh, a lot of the stuff, uh, uh,
coming out of Finland by Rita Kaltiala,
if you've ever read any of her work
And it's been echoed, you know, in,
in research in the United States.
But a lot of the kids that end
up identifying as transgender or
experiencing gender dysphoria seem to
struggle with peer belonging and sort
of community and social relationships
even prior to those experiences.
And I think that it makes sense then
that, you know, identifying as transgender
could become an avenue to sort of find
that community and belonging and kind
of skip, you, you can kind of skip the
steps you need to find your tribe in
time, and you get a built-in sort of
community and sort of the validation
and sort of the, um, I can understand
why those things are appealing
psychologically, but I think it's a, a
maladaptive short-term response to a,
a kind of larger developmental project.
And, uh, and I, I think the point you
made was really interesting about the
kind of OCD angle there, 'cause I've,
I've heard some people even point out
that, you know, there's an argument to
be made that gender dysphoria could in
some cases maybe be a subtype of, of OCD.
And I was thinking about a, a talk I
heard recently by, uh, Sarah Mittermaier,
uh, who used to write under the pen
name Eliza Mondegreen, where she writes
a lot about the kind of online sort of
subcultures where trans people gather
and kind of share stories and share
tips and talk about their experiences.
And one of the common things that she
talks about there is that, and you,
you, you nailed this, is that sort of
For a lot of people, sort of gender and
the congruence angle was not something
that they were really thinking about.
And then as they come to go deeper
and deeper into the gender stuff,
it becomes sort of like a growing
fixation, and the, and the, the
source of their dysphoria shifts.
So it's like, "Hey, I, you know,
I, I had no issues with my hands.
Now I think my hands look too masculine."
And then I do something about
my hands, and then it's my
facial hair, it's my, my neck.
It's…
And it, and sort of there's this
never-ending, there's this kind of, uh,
like you end up on this like hedonic
treadmill that you can't get off of.
You're just kind of
chasing the next thing.
And of course, that's, you
know, it's like, uh, trying
to-- It's a chimerical chase.
There's nothing to kind of…
You're never gonna be happy with
what you, with what you get.
And I, I notice a lot of people, and
it might take several years, it might
take a decade, but eventually realize
that they've been chasing something
for X amount of time, and they haven't,
their life hasn't improved in any
way, and they're kind of just been
in a, in like sort of like in a limbo
state and, or like a holding pen.
You know, they pursue this gender
thing, but the rest of their life
is kind of not going, um, according
to plan in maybe professional
ways or romantic or interpersonal.
And, um, it is interesting that
anecdotally it seems like the people
that get out of the gender stuff
and/or detransition or just decide not
to pursue social or medicalization,
that this, the secret is just
they stop thinking about gender.
They, they end up doing something out
in the world that kind of takes up
their time and energy and resources,
and sort of when they do that, uh, the,
the gender stuff kind of just naturally
disappears on its own because they're,
they're personally fulfilled or, or
occupied in ways that they weren't before.
Stephanie: Yeah.
Well said.
And with some of those young people,
it, it is a double-edged sword as
they're on their way out because they
are As you've just explained, building
identity, confidence, and competence
on real things, but at the same time
as they're doing so, they're giving
the new identity credit for it.
So that can be a little bit of a trap.
But I would say that having other things
going on in your life is one of a number
of factors I'd put into the formula for,
you know, predicting someone's success
of getting out sooner rather than later.
Um, I, I could dive into the
psychology aspect of stuff all day.
That's what I do the rest of the week.
Um, but I wanna kinda steer back
into your wheelhouse and the things
that, that you know about that I
don't, um, with regard to the APA.
Um, so how can we, how can
we get back to that subject?
'Cause y- you, you said that they've
been on your radar since at least
2024, and that they keep doubling down
on reaffirming the idea that gender
medicine is somehow evidence-based.
Joe: Yeah, I mean, even, even last,
I believe it was last month, the APA had,
like, a special issue in their flagship
journal, The American Psychologist,
that was basically solely dev- dedicated
to, like, transgender issues and,
you know, again, framing it as, like,
a, as a, a civil and human right.
And also I'm sure your, your, I'm
sure you've come across sort of the
minority stress framework before, which
presupposes that kind of any minority
group, if there is any kind of mental
health disparity, that those disparities
must be, you know, the product of
discrimination and stigma marginalization.
And the APA basically adopted
that, that sort of, that
framework, which I think is…
I, I think that the idea, the framework
I think is intuitive in a lot of ways,
but I've, I've unpack- you know, I've
done a lot of, I'm really interested
in the, the kind of minority stress
question and I, I mean, I think it's
a, there's a kind of a, an alternative
interpretation in a lot of cases.
So a lot of that entire research
literature is based on self-report
surveys, where they just ask
people basically, like, "Do
you have bad mental health?"
And then, "Do you feel
discriminated against?"
And you get into questions of sort of,
uh, I think rejection sensitivity, and J.
Michael Bailey has, has written a
lot about this, is kind of like an
alternative way of looking at this,
where, like, these, a lot of these
kids have preexisting mental health
issues that, you know, predate their
dysphoria diagnoses, and a lot of those
have, you know, negative heuristics or,
like, negativity biases, where you're
more predisposed to interpret innocuous
comments or whatever as discriminatory.
And, uh, I think that, that, that, I think
that's probably what's going on, that sort
of alternative reading of that literature.
No, like, that, sort of pointing that out
that there's a, an, an equally plausible
alternative hypothesis for that, for
that data is sort of beyond the pale.
Like, I, I don't see anyone really
writing mainstream psych articles about
that, um, besides, like, people like J.
Michael Bailey, for example.
Um, I think that the APA, their general
problem with them, I think, is, is
cultural and not just a matter of policy.
So they also had a new president who
just, uh, a new president-elect, and in
her writing, she, you know, dismissed,
uh, one of my colleagues at the Manhattan
Institute, uh, Colin Wright wrote an
article about this, where she dismissed
objectivity in science as an obstacle to
scientific integrity in this weird way.
It's just very strange for the leader
of a medical association that purports
to support, you know, high-quality
evidence talking about objectivity
being an obstacle to science.
Yeah, I think that you really need a
sort of, uh, an overhaul of the kind
of-- I think we need a new generation of
psychologists that are not sort of, uh,
that are really returning to kind of a
more, I don't even know what, how to put
it, developmentally informed approach to
psychology that sort of just acknowledges,
you know, the, the, the kind of the,
the inherent identity challenges of
adolescence and sort of the, the goals
of adolescence and that is not kind of
captured by a lot of these ideological
frameworks that might seem intuitive in
some ways, but are really kind of, uh…
Distinguishing between like
the map and the territory.
That like the territory is like what
things actually are, and the map is kind
of like the theory that we use to kind of
map the territory, and it's sort of the,
the problem that happens when your map
is just wrong and then you can't see the
world as it is anymore, and you end up
having, you know, adopting these kind of
unusual beliefs that might make sense in
your closed echo chamber but sort of don't
map onto other people's understanding
of, of kind of social reality.
Stephanie: And to your point, I'm glad
you brought up the minority stress model
because that is also a map, and I would
say oftentimes a quite inaccurate map of
the territory of what's really going on
in the minds of people with gender issues
Mixed up with other psychological issues.
And part of what makes the minority
stress narrative so dangerous
is that it points the finger at
people like you and me, right?
It says that it's our fault that
these patients are getting worse.
It's not that the treatments are bogus.
It's not that they're being lied to.
It's not that they're being harmed.
It's our fault, right?
If we would just stop having
conversations like this, then we
wouldn't be placing so much stress on
these poor minorities, and then they
could finally start to heal, then these
magical treatments would start to work.
Joe: Yeah, exactly.
And I think there was a, I think it was
a Trevor Project survey that might have,
that, you know, tried to argue that
states that ban youth gender medicine,
uh, are responsible for, like, what they
claim are worsening mental health by
the standards of self-report surveys,
which, you know, from a, from an evidence
standpoint are not super reliable
'cause we can't determine causality.
But they, like, in those surveys,
they would basically say things
like, you know, "Debates about this
policy, like, harm my mental health."
And it's interesting because it also,
it kinda does something that I think
psychology often tries to do the opposite
of, which is it encourages usually you to
sort of, to take control of, like, what
you can take control of and have, like, an
internal locus and all these other things.
And what this instead does is it
teaches you to kind of externalize
all your issues and to blame them
on sort of things outside yourself.
And I think that, you know, that sort of
pessimistic Negative thinking, I think
manifests itself in, in other areas
where there's kind of this tendency to
sort of, to blame society for kind of
all these issues and then kind of to
throw your hands up and say like, "We
can't fix them, and then we're just gonna
have to live and suffer in the interim."
And I, I don't think that seeing yourself
in those kind of, like as first and
foremost like a victim is good for
anyone's mental health or, you know.
I, I've written articles about the
problem with framing, you know,
conversations about the evidence
for youth gender medicine as sort of
transphobic or anti-trans or hateful.
Because it makes, it, it convinces
vulnerable, stressed out kids that
regular people that have a genuine
interest in their wellbeing, that
just to ask questions means that they
hate you or they don't want you to
live or they don't want you to thrive.
And I, I think that, you know, the
people that I know that work in this
space are g- are genuinely motivated
by, you know, by gender distressed youth
and they want what's best for them and
there's no sort of animus directed at
them for being trans-identified or,
uh, and I think that's kind of, that's
really sad in a lot of ways because I
think that a lot of people even on the
gender critical side, very sympathetic
and, and towards the trans-identified
and they just have a different sort
of, uh, a different perspective
on what's in their best interest.
Stephanie: And it's even worse than
that because that paranoid worldview
that you're describing doesn't just
cast their suspicion on strangers
on the internet discussing policies.
It, it affects their view of their own
parents Many of whom are my clients
or enrolled in my course, and people
like me who would like to help them,
therapists, the people who are the most
concerned, the most in a position to help.
And it is a very distorting ideology.
And I can see why psychology,
uh, was a path that called to
you in a different timeline.
And 'cause I, I keep wanting to go back to
policy, which is your area of expertise,
and we keep getting into more of the
psychology and philosophy side of things.
It is-- It has a magnetic
pull, doesn't it?
Joe: Well, I do wanna talk about
some of the, you know, what I think
the APA could do in the interim while
they- Oh, awesome … wait for a next,
you know, another, potentially another
generation of, of psychologists.
Uh, so I wrote a, yeah, I wrote an
article last week for In City Journal
that proposed, you know, some, what
I call low-hanging fruit reforms, uh,
for the APA, and this was specifically
for their accreditation standards.
And so these are their, their
program standards basically.
And thinking primarily about youth gender
medicine, I, I advocated for basically
a scientific integrity standard that
would encourage, basically encourage…
They already have a sort of like
an academic freedom, uh, standard,
but I think to be more explicit
that people should be allowed to
have different perspectives on
Contentious issues, especially when
I think the issue is unsettled.
And so related to that, I introduced,
you know, what, what could be
working definitions for when an
area is unsettled or contested.
That could be when there's, you know,
maybe different reputable clinical
practice guidelines that arrive at
different conclusions, or it could
be when the evidence for a particular
question is low certainty by the
standards of systematic reviews,
using some kind of objective benchmark
that we could reference that I think
just clears up a lot of ambiguity.
Um, so I think that sort of thing
I really like, especially because,
you know, the APA already claims
to support high-quality evidence.
Their program quality standards require
the latest evidence to be presented.
And so if all that-- if we take
them at face value that this is what
they care about and this is what
their, you know, their programs are
already committed to, uh, introducing
standards that buttress their evidence
quality, to me, there's no, there's no
contradiction or tension at, at all.
If anything, this would reinforce
their standards in, I think,
uh, in a, in a positive way.
Yeah, it remains to be seen.
I, I also think there are things
they could do about complaints,
particularly when it came to, you
know, the, the antisemitism issue.
I think introducing, uh, sort of having
to sort of keep better records for what
happens when complaints are lodged.
What was like the follow-up steps taken?
If there are, you know, credible
complaints made that they have to be
investigated, they can't just ignore them.
Sort of things like that would just make
it so that the f- the standards I think
are more, are more precise and less vague
and just easier to kind of operationalize
so that when there are questions about
a particular standard or whether or not,
you know, there's a violation of this
or that, there's just, you know, clear
parameters to work with so you can't
just hide behind, you know, vague…
Well, I'm sure you've read standard,
like the standards in Social work
programs or there, there's a lot
of like fluff and jargon buzzwords
Stephanie: American Counseling
Association ethics code is, is a mess.
I mean, tho- those ideas
sound good in theory.
And just to clarify, when you say
complaints, you're not talking about
board complaints about, uh, licensees.
That is a state board issue.
No, no, no.
These are, these are- You're
talking about internal complaints
…
Joe: complaints to-- Yeah, these
are complaints that would be specific
to the program and probably lodged with
the Commission on Accreditation itself.
Stephanie: Oh, specific
to an educational program.
Complaints about a, a graduate
training program, that's what you mean?
Joe: Yes, correct.
Correct.
Ah.
Exactly.
Yeah, these are for, these are
educational standards for doctoral
programs, internships, things like that.
So I'm thinking
Stephanie: about- Well, can you
tell us about those complaints then?
Joe: So, well, a lot of them
were not about, again, most of the
formal complaints that, that were
on the commission's radar were
not about, not about gender stuff.
I'm sort of extrapolating based on the
APA's positions that I don't see how
a program could endorse, you know, a
gender-critical position without being at
odds with the APA's understanding of what
evidence is based on their own definitions
when they, in, in, across their
position statements and amicus brief.
So if they say that, you know Gender
medicine is definitively evidence-based
and that sort of gender critical positions
are misinformation, you worry that
presenting those in those programs would
not meet the APA's definition of evidence.
So I thought I would sort of
preempt that by introducing
evidence standards specifically.
Stephanie: I guess I'm trying to get
a sense, as someone who's not involved
in the APA and not really involved in
any professional group, I'm just out
here on my own doing my own thing,
how deep do you think the rot runs?
I mean, do you think that there's enough
of a sort of base of thoughtful members
who are tired of seeing the nonsense?
Joe: I know that, you know, when
they recently, I forgot which last
posi- which position statement of
theirs came last, but it was voted on
by some, some group of APA members.
I don't know if that was the
APA at large or if it was a
particular task force or committee.
I think, you know,
there's always gonna be…
It's hard to know.
My experience, you know, talking to folks
at other medical associations is there
is a lot of, there, there is often a
lot of dissent towards, you know, the,
the gender affirmative status quo, but a
lot of people are too scared to kind of
voice that, I think because they don't
wanna be professionally ostracized.
They don't wanna, you know, lose the
backing of their colleagues or their
associ- I mean, there's obviously, it
sounds really easy to kind of make, to
come out in defense of that, but like if
those are your professional networks and
your peers, do you really want to be like
the black sheep in your group that's kind
of taking this position and especially if
it's not an issue you work on personally.
If you don't work with these
patients, it's like you're just
probably thinking like, "Do I
really wanna like die on this hill?"
Uh, there are people that are just
naturally principled and courageous,
and they would, they would, you
know, they would stick up for their
principles and need, and not need much
of, of a motivation or an impetus,
and there's lots of other people that
are just, they don't wanna rock the
boat and they wanna keep their careers
intact and they rather just kind of…
Especially I think when the issue is
framed And this is why I really object
to the, the civil and human rights stuff
is the framing of it is then who wants
to be accused of being like anti-human
rights or anti-LGBTQ or anti-civil rights?
And we, and we can get into like kind
of, you know, the, the, you know,
the status of gender identity as like
the basis for like an immutable like
sort of protected characteristic.
I don't think it is because I, I
don't think it's one thing and I
think it, you know, I don't think
gender dysphoria is one thing.
I don't think the people that
identify as transgender are having
the same experiences or situations.
I think it, it ends up bringing a lot
of people that might have some overlap
in terms of experiences, but I think
there's a lot of people experiencing
different things, and the criteria is
just so vague that it kind of, uh, you
know, going back to like the concept creep
and the gender incongruence framework,
that it just, it causes a lot more people
to think of themselves in those terms.
So to answer your question, I don't
know the extent to which the APA is--
I mean, what, what I find interesting
is that, I mean, I don't know.
I mean, HHS, if you didn't know
this, HHS some weeks ago sent the
APA an ultimatum along with another
of other medical associations
basically saying, "Hey, you have your
position on youth gender medicine.
It's at odds with our report on best
practices for gender dysphoria and
the evidence that we have access to.
Can you tell us kind of how you
arrived at your position and how you
reconcile, you know, the findings of
these like European countries and their
medical practice reversals and the
HHS report, like with your position?"
And they were given 10 days to
respond, and I believe they haven't
responded as far as I know publicly.
I mean, it's publicly out there that like
their position is at odds with the latest
evidence, and I do wonder if they're
hoping it'll just go away and they can
kind of just outlast the administration,
and I don't know what their The, you
know, the, the risk, the, the calculus of
these associations is really fascinating
because I get why they don't wanna
s- change positions, that it's very
embarrassing reputationally to admit that
you were, like, this wrong on an issue.
I understand that.
At the same time, though, they're engaging
in, like, this short-term survival
strategy that kind of, you know, maybe
keeps them okay in the short term.
But, like, in the long term, the
longer you hold out, I think it's,
it's m- it's worse for your reputation.
I, I just wonder if they're hoping
that it'll go away and they can kinda
memory hole the situation and just
kinda pretend like it never happened.
Stephanie: Let's take a short
break here, because this part
is for the parents listening.
A lot of parents do their research
on trans issues by listening to
podcasts like this one, and frankly,
a lot of them get overwhelmed fast.
They come away more hopeless
than when they started and no
better at talking to their kid.
So I wanna be clear about something.
This podcast is only a side gig for me.
It's where I get to explore
whatever I'm curious about.
If you're looking for real help with
gender issues in your family You need
a toolkit built specifically for that,
one that helps you get your feet under
you, become a better communicator,
and work smarter, not harder.
This podcast won't give you that.
My course will.
ROGD Repair is my course and
community for parents like you.
It covers the psychology behind what's
happening with your kid, and it gives
you the communication tools to get
through to them, how to stop arguing
about identity and start rebuilding
connection, how to stay calm when your
child is aggressive, and how to hold
a boundary without apologizing for it.
Most importantly, ROGD Repair teaches
you to connect with the part of your kid
that's unsure about all of this, and to
help that part of them, however buried,
find a way out that's truly their own.
Inside the program, you will
find in-depth lessons on all of
this, and I keep adding more.
You'll hear several desistance stories,
comprehensive interviews with parents
who used the tools in this program and
watched their kids find their way back.
There are also guided meditations for
the moments when you need to steady
yourself before you can steady anyone
else, plus a growing library of scripts
I've written for use in specific
situations with parents that I coached.
There's Repair Bot, an AI assistant
you can ask about your specific
situation at 2:00 in the morning,
and there's a community of parents
who understand and are working
alongside you to apply these tools.
That's a lot of material,
and the right place to start
depends on your personality.
Every parent in this situation
gets stuck in a different way.
Some of you are the sentinel, always
on alert, scanning every text and every
mood for the next sign of trouble.
Some of you are the eggshell walker, so
afraid of setting off an explosion that
you've stopped saying anything real.
And some of you are the penitent.
Your child knows exactly where your guilt
lives about the divorce or the depression
or the thing you said in anger, and
presses on it whenever they need leverage,
so you apologize for your boundaries
while you're trying to set them, and
undermine yourself in the process.
None of these or the other
patterns identified in my
quiz make you a bad parent.
They're patterns that are
understandable, but each one calls
for a different starting point.
That's what my quiz gives you.
It takes about eight minutes.
It asks about your child, your family,
and how you actually respond under stress.
Then it emails you your main
archetype, your runners-up, and a
list of lessons from ROGD Repair
chosen for your specific pattern.
So instead of facing 200 plus
lessons and wondering where to begin,
you'll know just where to start.
At the end of your quiz results, you'll
find a code for half off your first month.
So visit
ROGDRepair.com/quiz.
Find out which parent you
are and where to begin.
Now, back to the episode.
Stephanie: Well, that brings us to a
somewhat different topic, but something
that I've been asking myself lately and
asking a variety of my guests, so my
most consistent listeners might recognize
some version of this question from
other conversations I've had recently.
So the question boils down to essentially
what is your take on how long this
nonsense is gonna stick around?
Do you think that it's like a pandemic
wildfire that'll eventually burn itself
out and where we'll look back in horror
in 50 years the same way we look back
on lobotomies, which is a position
I hear a lot of people compare it to
in this sort of medical malpractice?
Or do you think that this is more of a
Pandora's box, the toothpaste is out of
the tube, the cat's out of the bag, this
is now part of the culture, it's endemic,
it's insidious, it's here to stay?
How do you tend to think about
gender identity ideology?
Joe: I've kind of split down the
middle in the sense that I do think the
landscape has definitely changed quite a
lot since I first started working on the
issue when Democrats were in the White
House and no medical association had
broken with consensus, and this was before
the Supreme Court upheld Tennessee's
Uh, ban on youth gender medicine.
And I think a lot has clearly changed
since then, and I think public
sentiment seems, from what I, what
I personally see, seems to be fairly
against youth gender medicine.
But at the same time, I also recognize
that sort of the, the tentacles, if you
will, of gender ideology are everywhere.
And it's a, it's a cultural issue
that's, you know, it's in education,
it's in higher education, it's
in continuing medical education,
it's in our professional, it's
in law, it's in the judiciary.
It's kind of just everywhere, and I
think that the average person doesn't
even realize the extent to which these
ideas have sort of marched through
the institutions and have taken hold.
And I think getting rid of them there is
not, is not simply a thing like where,
you know, you s- you flip a switch
and like the federal government just
kind of does away with it everywhere.
Like, I don't think that's how, like,
cultural engineering really works.
And so I think that it's gonna be
probably a longer type of situation.
I think that maybe, maybe it'll become
widespread consensus that the practice
is not, you know, evidence-based or
safe, but I think that there's gonna
be, especially when, you know, in
the United States where, you know,
the, we have decentralized medicine
and, and federalism and states
can kinda set their own policies.
I do worry that it could be a lot like an
abortion situation where you have states
that allow gender medicine and states
that don't allow gender medicine, and
we'll just kinda live in siloed worlds
where one part of the country engages in
these kind of practices and one doesn't.
Um, but it's really hard to predict
the future because it's, it's
just hard to know how our culture
will kind of evolve going forward.
So although I've, I've-- on the flip
side, I've heard some preliminary stories
and, uh, people talking about preliminary
data where they're seeing sort of a
decrease in, in youth that identify as
transgender, which could suggest that,
you know, this, the ROGD population
is kind of a unique population at a
particular kind of like historical moment,
and then maybe after that it, it will
be, it, it, it kind of will cool down,
um, and won't be kind of what it was.
So that, that's kind of
as opposed to, uh Like a
multi-generational type of situation.
It's, uh, it, it's like the ROGD
cohort and kind of the, the ra- the
after effects of that, of like what
happens to that patient population.
That's, yeah, I don't know if that
an- that satisfies your question.
It's, I think it is…
I do, I do think the evidence, though,
is, is kind of overwhelming enough right
now that it would be hard to return to
the status quo, for example, where like
under the Biden administration, I, I
don't know how many people know this,
but the Biden administration passed
a rule that modified Section 1557 of
the Affordable Care Act and basically
introduced, uh, gender identity in
there under sex, uh, as an extension
of sex, and then basically argued
explicitly that if you didn't render
affirming care practices, uh, you were
engaging in healthcare discrimination.
And like their f- explicit framing was
like If you are gonna render, like, a
hysterectomy to a patient that, like,
medically requires one, then you also
have to render a hysterectomy to someone
that desires one solely for the purpose
of, like, affirming their gender.
And th- I don't think we'll
go back to that world, right?
Where that is sort of just…
I don't think th- they'll be that
bold to kind of do that again.
I just don't think it would fly, but,
but I don't think it's gonna be over.
Stephanie: Having studied this issue
for the past several years, what are
your thoughts about the direction that
the counseling field is moving overall?
Joe: Designing targeted
interventions for gender dysphoria
in psychotherapeutic spaces, I think,
needs to be, like, a high priority.
Because if you're gonna say, if you're
gonna take medical transition and social
transition and things like that off
the table, you know, the argument for
psychotherapy is that it has a more
favorable, you know, risk-benefit profile
because you're not f- there's little
ri- uh, not that there aren't risks
of psychotherapy, but they're, it's a
lot less risky than, you know, taking
cross-sex hormones or taking puberty
blockers or having a double mastectomy.
But there isn't a lot of,
like, high-quality evidence
evaluating psychotherapies for
the treatment of gender dysphoria.
I mean, I've seen some promising,
like, anecdotal stuff there.
I've heard about some researchers
trying to develop a kind of CBT-based
focus on this, which I think would
be particularly interesting because
they're not focusing on sort of the
distress or the pathol- they're,
they don't even see it as pathology.
They just see it really as, like,
essentially a, a belief about the self.
And I think CBT lends itself well
to sort of altering self-beliefs.
And I, I think that if I was a therapist
now and someone told me that they thought
they were the opposite sex, I don't
know if my approach would be all that
different in the sense that I would
be curious about why they thought they
were the opposite sex and what does it
mean to them to be the opposite sex.
Like, the idea that you would just
affirm a patient and say, "Yes, you
are," and not be, like, remarkably
curious about, like, why a 14-year-old
girl thinks they're a boy To me, that
seems like, you know, developing kind
of more specific targeted therapies
to think about that, that get at…
And you're gonna need, you know, more
basic research on sort of the nature
of ROGD and sort of, you know, the,
the kind of the, maybe the, the reasons
why this population does think that
they're the opposite sex and kind of
the, the comorbidities that they're
dealing with, uh, that maybe have
to be treated before anything else.
Like there's, I mean, a strong argument
to be made that, and I think, uh, Dr.
Kaltiala in Finland has made this argument
that basically youth that have psychiatric
comorbidities prior to medicalization,
those psychiat- the psychiat- the burden
of psychiatric illness doesn't seem to
reduce as you go through medicalization.
And so what that says is that if
you're struggling with particular
psychiatric issues, you do need to
get a grip on those because it doesn't
seem like they're going anywhere.
And so I think targeted psychotherapies
for If not gender dysphoria, then,
you know, the comorbidities associated
with gender dysphoria, I think would
be, uh, a step in the right direction.
But you're gonna need, uh, you're
gonna, you're gonna need therapists
and clinicians and social workers and
psychiatrists and psychologists that
are interested in thinking about,
you know, this issue outside of the
affirmative paradigm, which is obviously
very narrow in what it prescribes.
Stephanie: Earlier you used the word
developmental to describe the model
of thinking about psychology that we
need here, and I think that's a really
important way to look at it, especially
when the so-called gender dysphoria
or so-called incongruence or the trans
identity is typically taking root at
such a, an impressionable time in a
young person's life during oftentimes
windows of peak neuroplasticity.
So much of the model that I teach is
based on understanding the significance
of the neuroplasticity that's available to
adolescents and young adults and how that
plays a role in the formation of these
powerful beliefs and why the behavior
of the parents in the household and the
choices that they make are so influential.
Not to say that you're not losing
leverage rapidly as a parent in this
situation, because you are, and parents
need to catch up to where their leverage
is actually at at this point in time
with their kid as opposed to where they
remember it being a few years prior.
But there's really so much happening in
the brain, um, making new connections,
pruning connections from childhood that
are not needed anymore as one moves into
the future and, and the neuroplasticity
aspect of things really does explain
so much about how youth end up coming
to believe these things so sincerely.
I explain a lot of the mechanics of
this in my course, and I notice when
I hear someone like you talking about
people working on these models, there's
this little impatient part of me
that's like, "Oh, I know how it works.
Ask me."
Like, I've got 200 lessons on this
in my course, essentially providing
psychoeducation to parents on what's
going on in their kids' brains
and, and I think we do have the
tools in psychology, absolutely, to
understand what's going on with these
kids, and it's not just one thing.
The problem is the political climate.
Joe: I mean, it even, like I, I'm
fascinated by the Like the, the embrace
of the concept of gender identity as well,
and, you know, there's often this claim
that, you know, kids know their gender
identity when they're, they're very young.
And but then it's fascinating to me
because gender is defined in, in like
these social ways, and it seems like
they're often, and I think Alex Byrne makes
this point in his book, uh, "The Trouble
With Gender," that essentially what,
what's happening is people are conflating
a child's, like, growing sense of, like,
sex constancy with gender identity.
And so what happens is, like, a kid
that might be gender non-conforming
could be recognizing at a certain
age that they, that they don't…
That they are different in
some meaningful ways from, you
know, other boys or, or girls.
But then, like, if in the gender paradigm
though, then everyone around you tells
you that that difference means that you
are the opposite sex, where in just the
sex constancy thing, they'd be like,
"Hey, yeah, you're just like a gender
non-conforming person," and like now you
realize that, that sex is constant and
you're a little different, but you're
not, your, your personality and interest
and behavior doesn't define your sex.
But in g- in gender
identity theory, it does.
Like they, they actually sw- like the
best way to frame gender identity to me
is like they literally argue that your
gender is more real than your sex, and
your gender is defined in relation to
sex stereotypes, and then you end up
being your sex is basically determined
by which stereotypes you conform to.
It's a very weird, regressive sort of…
It's strange to me that like psychologists
who, especially if you're, like, a
developmental psychologist, how anyone
could, could absorb th- this idea and not
immediately be like, "Yeah, this is crazy
to think that, like, a seven-year-old
has, like, a working understanding of
gender as, like, independent than sex."
Like, if you're gonna, like, if you're
gonna treat gender as, like, you know,
the sort of the cultural assumptions
or mappings that we project onto sex,
to think that, like, a child has,
like, the powers of abstraction to
draw that distinction is, like, to me
absurd, and explains a w- a lot of the
problems that we find ourselves in.
Stephanie: And it's even worse than that,
because the people who are committed
to this ideology would apply that
logic in the case of what you call a
gender non-conforming, or I prefer to
call a gender atypical child, right?
That, that tomboyish girl or that
boy who likes to play with dolls.
They would look at that child through
the lens of this narrative that, oh, they
know who they are from a- an early age.
But notice how the narrative flips
when the kid who identifies as trans
as a teenager was actually very
gender typical up until that point.
I have a big heart for the girly girls.
There's a lot of discourse on X and
Substack and places about save the
tomboys, save the gay kids, but I have a
big heart for the girls who are actually
very gender typical until they got
wrapped up in this, and then they flip.
And so the gender ideologues would not say
that those girls knew who they are from
an early age based on their childhoods.
Joe: I was just gonna ask is,
I've heard some people anecdotally,
you know, it seems o- it seems more
intuitive that, you know, the gender
non-conforming kids would find
themselves in this situation thinking,
you know, they're the opposite sex.
But I have heard anecdotally that a
lot of, that it is a lot of girly girls
end up thinking that they're trans men.
And, you know, you actually I have
experience working with these populations.
Does that jive with your experience?
Stephanie: Yeah, absolutely.
And the good news is for especially
our parents in the audience, that,
uh, the girls who were more feminine
in childhood seem anecdotally to
be the ones most likely to desist,
especially with good parenting,
and that's what ROGD Repair is for.
I'm happy to announce that there is a
new lesson, Desistance Story Number Four,
uh, where a mother shares about her girly
girl who adopted a trans identity right at
puberty, went into that sort of dark cave
that a lot of these girls disappear into.
And thanks to her wise parenting using
the techniques that I teach in my course,
her daughter did emerge and is now
flourishing in her identity as a young
woman and back to feminine behavior.
So the good news is these girls do
desist more easily with, with wise
moves, but it's really scary as a
parent watching them go into that hole.
And part of how I describe this
is, I call it the masc mask.
So the mask of masculinity that
these girls are hiding behind,
it's not about their real self,
which is what the narrative says.
It's about the fantasy of what
masculinity represents to them,
which includes, you know, early
latent aspects of sexuality, right?
Attraction to masculinity, um,
but also includes the fantasy of
being strong and invulnerable in
a world that's, uh, showing them
that there are, there are reasons,
reasons to feel unsafe being female.
Joe: It kind of reminds me a little
bit of like, uh And I don't know much
about, like I haven't engaged with this
that much, but from what I do know, it
reminds me of like, kind of like Carl
Jung's concept of like, what is it?
The, uh, the anima and the
whatever the alternative-
Stephanie: Animus.
Joe: The animus, yeah, that
you're kind of wanting to kind of
be or incorporate, you know, aspects
of like the, your repressed feminine
or repressed masculine in a way.
And I do think my own personal belief is
that people that have, like that integrate
like the masculine and feminine sides
of themself are like more well-adjusted.
That's my per- that's
my personal intuition.
I can't prove that, but I, I
have a feeling that it's true.
Stephanie: I agree, and I think
that adopting the identity and the
belief system stands in the way of
that, stands in the way of so many
aspects of healthy development.
But it also stands in the way of
developing the healthy aspects of
those masculine attributes that
girls do need in order to become
well-rounded adults, as you say.
Many of these girls are very fragile.
Joe: What do you make of the argument
that, um, that, a- and I don't know
like what percentage of, you know,
youth this applies to, but that a
lot of it is like girls that are like
uncomfortable with or they're scared
by puberty or sexuality, and so the
transmasc thing is kind of like a way
to kind of like manage that in a way.
Stephanie: Yeah, absolutely.
And it's Not always because
of any particular trauma.
Um, many of these girls were raised
quite well and they were kept
safe, but exposure to pornography
can do a number on a girl's brain.
Um, and even with girls who weren't
exposed to it directly, um, culture
itself can, um, make girls feel quite
insecure about, uh, how they're going
to be looked at, how they're going to
be treated, what's going to be valued.
Many of these girls are quite bright
and gifted, and sadly, hiding behind
the mask of masculinity for some of
these girls, oftentimes without trauma,
is simply a way for them to feel like
they're being recognized for their
intellect rather than for their body.
And I think it's really sad that
they feel the need to hide, uh, their
bodies and put themselves on a path to
eventually harm their bodies just as
a way of saying, "Hey, respect me as
a person with interesting thoughts."
Joe: Yeah, that's, uh,
that's really interesting.
And I've noticed, uh, I've noticed in
a few, a number of studies I've seen
that, I, I think in Lisa Littman's,
uh, first ROGD paper in particular too,
she talked about, like, I mean, it's
self-report for parents, but, like,
most of these parents, like, I think it
was, like, over 75% or over 70% of the
parents thought that, like, you know,
their kids were gifted or very bright.
And I've seen other studies of, uh,
different trans populations where
they're similarly very intelligent.
I always kind of wondered, like,
what's going on here exactly.
Stephanie: Well, in some ways you have to
be very intelligent to believe something
so stupid, because a, a highly gifted
mind likes to make itself into pretzels.
It likes to make nonsensical
beliefs make sense.
It's like this endless puzzle.
I think that's one aspect.
Another is that many of these kids have
really high verbal IQs, and there's no way
to say this without bragging, I do too.
I have a very high verbal IQ, and
that's part of why I can do this work.
It's part of why I can
understand these kids.
It's part of why I can coach parents
on the communication techniques,
because to a parent for whom emotional
intelligence or verbal abilities aren't
their, necessarily their wheelhouse,
they might wanna say something in a
particular way, and I can put it in a
slightly different way that sounds almost
identical to the parent, and they can't
even notice what the difference is.
But yet these kids, some of them have
what I call sort of a key and lock brain,
the high verbal IQ kids do, where things
have to be worded a particular way.
Especially when you have high
neuroticism or when you have an OCD-type
profile, sometimes things have to
be worded in a very specific way in
order to get through to their head.
Joe: Yeah.
It also remind- it just gets into too that
there's, like, lots of different kind of,
like, subtypes and, like, manifestations
of Of intelligence as well, and that
I, I can see why it would be-- why,
like, kind of highly verbal people and,
like, the abstraction they're capable
of could lead you down that, that road.
Although it is interesting the kind
of the amount of, like, when you
deal with, like boys who think that
they're girls, there's, there seems
to be a lot of, like, more of a
mathematical spatial kind of, uh-
Stephanie: Yeah
…
Joe: lower IQ.
Stephanie: These are, these
are typically very boyish boys.
Not really, not usually the
sporty, athletic, rough and tumble,
although we do see that as well.
But the, the nerdy boys, the programmers,
the gamers, the ones who left to their
own devices would spend 16 hours a
day on their computers, um, those are
the boys who end up down this path.
If parents aren't willing to learn
about the sexual component of this,
they're gonna have a really hard time.
Um, because e- Are you talking
Joe: about boys specifically?
Stephanie: Yeah.
Yeah, I mean, there's a sexual
component both ways, but a lot of
parents have real trouble seeing their
boy's aggression and sexuality because
they remember him as a sweet boy.
They wanna look at him through the
eyes of just being their little angel.
And, you know, sweet, innocent,
smart, high-achieving boys also have
sexuality and aggression, because
sexuality and aggression are universal
elements of what it is to be human,
and they're a big part of what we
need to integrate, um, to grow up.
And so I think these boys have a real
particular trouble with that, and their
parents have a hard time seeing it.
Joe: Uh, yeah, a, a talk I just
heard over the weekend basically got
at that idea where they talked about
how a lot of boys in this area are
basically, like, scared of their own,
like, capacity for normal sexuality, and
they're kind of just, like, threatened
by it and, like, uncomfortable by it.
And so, like, they also
wanna kind of opt out.
Absolutely.
They can, they can- And it makes
sense if you're, like, a…
Yeah, if you're sensitive and you're kind
of, you know, you wanna be, like, a, a,
a feminist ally when you're a teenager,
but it's very complicated, and I can
see where you're just like- They think
Stephanie: they can hide it
"Oh, I don't wanna even play this game."
Yeah.
They think they can hide it in
femininity, and it's, the masc
mask can be more convincing.
A girl can have an easier
time convincing the world that
she's a boy than vice versa.
Um, the boys attempting to hide
their sexual and aggressive impulses
are very much wolves in sheep's
clothing with their snouts and
their ears sticking out, I mean.
But I think there is a powerful fantasy
that we need to explore psychologically,
nonetheless, of the idea that a boy can
fully conceal or deny even to himself
his sexual and aggressive impulses.
And I feel bad that these boys are being
lied to, because the reality for the vast
majority of women, I think, is that we
have far more trust and feel far more
secure around a man who has actually
integrated those parts of his personality
and understands that he's a man and
is comfortable in his skin as a man.
Whereas men who conceal their
motives Are the most off-putting,
and I think sadly a lot of these
boys are going to end up very alone.
No matter how much people fawn over them
and affirm them outwardly, that doesn't
mean that's how people feel deep down.
Joe: That's interesting,
and that's sad also.
Stephanie: It is.
I appreciate you turning the tables
and asking me some questions.
It's, it's always nice to be
able to talk about my work.
Joe: I mean, it just seems
like how conversations normally
go, like organically go, you know?
And I'm also really interested in
the psychology of this and the, and
people that actually get to work with
the patients 'cause I don't have that
experience, and so I talk to a lot of
clinicians, but it's always great to kinda
get, you know, clinical kind of anecdotes
and stories that kind of to, to add to the
toolkit with, you know, the more impartial
kind of, you know, research literature or
evidence reviews or whatever it might be.
Stephanie: Hmm, back to your research
on the clinical side of things.
Um, you and I met in the context
of some of your research into the
so-called conversion therapy laws.
So I'd love to maybe wrap
up by revisiting that topic.
What's your perspective on the
current status of these so-called
conversion therapy bills?
Joe: Well, the good news is that
when we last spoke, it was before the
Supreme Court case, uh, in, uh, Chiles
versus Salazar, which struck down, I
believe, Colorado's, uh, conversion
therapy law So that's favorable in the
sense that it, you know, it, uh, creates a
different kind of, uh, legal environment.
I mean, I've never understood the…
I think it was really smart by people
that drafted those conversion therapy
laws to kind of intentionally conflate
sexual orientation and gender identity,
and kind of piggyback off the research
on sexual orientation change efforts.
Um, even though there's very little
to no data on gender identity change
efforts, and gender identity, for many
reasons, is not like sexual orientation.
It's seemingly not, like, I
think, uh, what's his name?
I put this in my article.
James Cantor has a famous quote from a,
I think it might be an American Academy
of Pediatrics fact check, where he
says, like, "It makes no sense to talk
about conversion because, like, most
boys desist to their normal state."
So, like, the idea,
like, that they were…
It's kind of like a misframing of the
problem that the, especially when you
look at the, you know, the historical
desistance literature, most people that
are dysphoric don't stay dysphoric.
That itself is not a static category, and
neither is gender identity itself, because
people, obviously the, you know, the
existence of detransitioners, and we're
seeing, you know, more and more surveys
on the number of patients that, like,
discontinue taking cross-sex hormones
and puberty blockers, and all the old
research is based on, like, a totally
different patient population that's
been screened in more specific ways.
And it makes sense that, you know To me,
it, it's just a complete, like, misnomer
to, to label it conversion efforts.
And I think you need to be able to-- And
to, in fairness, and we talked about this
at the time, a lot of those laws do have
carve-outs for exploratory psychotherapy.
But the problem is that there's still
the concern with the way the laws are
worded that, you know, there would be a
chilling effect in anyone who is doing
non-affirming therapies is gonna be scared
to, to work with those populations 'cause
they don't wanna get accused of violating
the conversion therapy law, right?
Like in your, in your situation.
Like, they don't wanna…
And it makes sense.
I mean, why would you-- If you could work
in other areas of practice, why would
you wanna work with gender distressed
youth and risk getting, like, audited
by your state medical board, you know?
Stephanie: Yeah.
It does create dilemmas for clinicians,
and for any therapist in the audience,
I would refer them to my conversation,
my most recent conversation with Chris
Legg, because we talk about that chilling
effect that many people feel, and he's,
he's looked into it and has a rather
encouraging message for therapists.
Joe: I've heard that, too, that
there was an article written by, it was a
couple years ago, someone on Wesley Yang's
Substack, a psychologist, I believe,
wrote an article about how, like, there
were very few, if virtually no actual,
like, like, findings against therapists.
Like, no one had, like, been
punished or had their license
taken away seemingly at the time.
I don't know if that's changed since.
But, but as you said, the threat
of that is the, is the, was
the, is the larger issue, right?
Not just the-- It's just the risk.
You don't wanna put yourself in that,
and you don't wanna be stressed out
about, you know, being at odds with your
s- with your medical board, you know?
Um, your licensing board, sorry.
I should add, uh, the, uh, someone from
when I wrote my article on conversion
therapy laws for City Journal like two
years ago, someone from, I believe The
Trevor Project reached out and they
wanted to issue a, like, rebuttal in
City Journal, and I asked them, I was
like: "Hey, I read the rebuttal and it
basically repeated Just like a string
of falsehoods that my article debunked.
I was like, "That's interesting,
but like how about we do, you know,
a public debate about conversion
therapy laws and like we can get into
like the nuances of the position?"
I'm like in completely in good
faith, like I think lots of people
would wanna understand the issue.
And of course, radio silence,
did not take me up on the offer.
I was more than happy to-- I even told
him I would have a private debate.
I'd have a private
discussion with him about it.
Like, we can just talk.
We don't even have to make it public, and
he just never followed up with me at all.
So which tells me there's a…
I do wonder at sometimes, at times if
like the people that, you know, support
conversion therapy bans or whatever,
if they- they've actually ever read or
encountered the information on the other
side, or if they just, they really think
that they just, they're just in an echo
chamber that, that has convinced them
that their position is unassailable,
and they I just wonder if it's bad faith
or if they're just kind of deluded.
I don't know which one it is.
Stephanie: I don't know that there's
actually a clear line between those two.
Joe: Well, one is knowing
better and then being manipulative
and kind of more Machiavellian.
The other is, like, not knowing better
and sort of just, like, you're not
act- You really think you're right.
You're wrong, but you
just think you're right.
Like, an Elizabeth Holmes, I think of
as someone who, like, believes her own
lies, and it would be difficult to, like-
Stephanie: But is also
quite Machiavellian.
Joe: Totally Machiavellian, but
the question becomes you, you can't
hold someone accountable that has no
self-awareness and, like, has no, like,
continuity of self from moment to moment
and just, like, really believes the…
Like, I don't know.
I don't know.
And maybe, maybe some
of that's an act, but-
Stephanie: To be continued.
We'll end on that cliffhanger.
Um, Joe Figliolia, so nice
to chat with you again.
Tell people where they can find you.
Joe: Uh, you can find me at the
Manhattan Institute, uh, website.
Uh, also, I write a sort of a, a
weekly, uh, I would call it an update
on gender identity policies, uh,
once a week, it's a newsletter, the
Gender Debrief, if you're interested.
And once a month, we do a federal policy
update that kind of, uh, gives everyone
sort of a, a series of updates on gender
identity policies from federal agencies.
So HHS, uh, DOE, DOJ, FTC,
FCC, things like that.
Stephanie: Are those on Substack?
Joe: Uh, this is all on, uh,
the Manhattan Institute website.
Stephanie: Ah, got it.
Okay.
Well, we will make sure to include
those links in the show notes,
and thank you so much for your
work and for your time today.
Joe: Thank you.
Stephanie: Thank you for listening to
You Must Be Some Kind of Therapist.
If you enjoyed this episode, kindly take a
moment to rate, review, share, or comment
on it using your platform of choice.
And of course, please remember,
podcasts are not therapy,
and I'm not your therapist.
Special thanks to Joey Pecoraro for
this awesome theme song, Half Awake,
and to Pods by Nick for production.
For help navigating the impact
of the gender craze on your
family, be sure to check out my
program for parents, ROGD Repair.
Any resource you heard mentioned
on this show, plus how to get in
touch with me, can all be found
in the notes and links below.
Rain or shine, I hope you will step
outside to breathe the air today.
In the words of Max Ehrmann, "With
all its sham, drudgery, and broken
dreams, it is still a beautiful world."
